Jump to content

Absurd Single Discussion


Haters Gonna Hate
 Share

Recommended Posts

5 minutes ago, Budd Dwyer said:

yeah yeah usual bullshit but you never backed up a single argument in your lifetime

 

 

Saying the cd leftovers were better than Anastasia is already asinine enough to make you look like an idiot in a normal GNR board so... maybe a few edgy teenagers/zoomer can share your opinion, the majority doesn't. You are in the minority in the fanbase. Deal with it

let's leave it there about who is a clown. who has/needs "credibility" (btw who the fuck needs credibility besides the so called "insiders" lol)

We are just screenames on a dead rock bands forum. Who gives a shit? this is already serious for you? in 20 fucking 21? LOL

 

You are a fucking bot who can't even shut his mouth and constantly quoting every post i've made and iu've already proved conclusions of these shitty arguments

 

Yeah and people taken YOU seriosuly, i see. You are here since 2010 right? But you fucked off back to gyno for years lol

Fucking lol

 

Dish it out? You are the one who can't shut his mouth and constantly parroting the same shit in every thread and your only retort is the "zero credibility, clown" line which yout often spat out after somebody (not even only me) handed your ass to you in an argument

Once again. Lolocaust

 

the CD leftovers are way better than Anastasia.   But you have slash's cock so far down your throat it must be affecting your hearing.   Its jut funny you use Anastasia that overrated song as an example.   But maybe its just your shitty taste, so that could make sense

 

I love how triggered you get at me replying to your posts.  If you dont like people replying to you, then either block them or dont post. But it just shows what a little bitch you are, all the shit talking you do on here. when someone challenges you you start to cry. You are pathetic.    But keep showing everyone what a little bitch you are. Its fun to expose people like you.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Tremolo said:

Anastasia seems to be the one song that keeps being brought over and over up every time Slash’s creative output is the object of criticism. I assume that to those who have been following his career, it is a song that stands out.

 

Well, I gave it a chance a few years ago and it sounds like a wet fart. Completely overrated.

I've always tried to like Slash's stuff, mostly unsuccessfully.

I have no idea why Anastasia got so much buzz either, I think it's mediocre.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, Budd Dwyer said:

Numbers don't lie. That's all needs to be said, but i'm not going into an endless loop about the quality vs. quantity, pop vs. rock. mainstream vs. underground talent bullshit

We've already did those lines and it was pointless because you are a fan of a band which never even existed

Lol

You're biased as fuck and i (was) a GNR fan. Not an Axl fan only. You seem to like Axl's visions. His directions. I never will. GNR is not Axl

Case closed

 

I've already answered and refuted ALL of your arguments over the past few months so

 

Fuck off, i think

Stop wasting my time and stop quoting me please

 

 

Numbers don't lie?  So using your logic  Nickelback must be an amazing band since they sell so many albums.  Or You must really love Bieber because of all the album he sells.    You keep showing what an utter clown you are.

 

Its just funny you claim I am biased after all the drivel you have posted.  Here is something that needs to get through your empty head.  Not everyone has the same tastes as you.   Everyone is biased when it comes to music, movies, art, whatever they like.     You act like music is objective when its not.  Not everyone will have your shitty tastes. so maybe you should learn that lesson.

 

Its also funny you tell me to stop quoting you yet you are the one quoting me.  but oh right you have  to have the last word because you are a little bitch.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Doctor Dom said:

I've always tried to like Slash's stuff, mostly unsuccessfully.

I have no idea why Anastasia got so much buzz either, I think it's mediocre.

 

 

And that is just a perfect example at how lackluster slash's solo work is when most of them pick that as his best song.  that speaks volumes. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah Slash’s solo stuff, for the most part is not good. Each Snakepit album has a couple good songs along with the 2010 and his first myles album and VR has like 4 songs I go back too. Overall, even with it being a disaster and a lot of the songs being much worse than earlier demos, I would rather listen to CD than anything Slash has done since leaving gnr. 
 

A couple of those instrumentals bucket did do have serious potential, shanklers turned into Shacklers and that instrumental is not as good as Me and My Elvis and Prom Violence. I guess we will see what they turned into. Like I said earlier judging from Absurd, it seems like Slash will keep the main riffs of the songs the same which is good. However hopefully down the line we’ll hear the 2003-2004 versions of these songs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Doctor Dom said:

I've always tried to like Slash's stuff, mostly unsuccessfully.

I have no idea why Anastasia got so much buzz either, I think it's mediocre.

 

 

And that is just a perfect example at how lackluster slash's solo work is when most of them pick that as his best song.  that speaks volumes.  For guitar work, id put beggars and hangers over  that song 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One last thing about those leftover CD session songs. I would 100% rather hear the songs with vocals of the Bucket, Brain and Finck versions than just an album of slash and duff re-doing those songs and removing the old players from 99-04.

 

If slash, duff and Axl are going to put out an album at least make it with new new songs they all wrote together and not re-hashed CD era songs

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, dave-gnfnr2k said:

One last thing about those leftover CD session songs. I would 100% rather hear the songs with vocals of the Bucket, Brain and Finck versions than just an album of slash and duff re-doing those songs and removing the old players from 99-04.

 

If slash, duff and Axl are going to put out an album at least make it with new new songs they all wrote together and not re-hashed CD era songs

 

Brain is on Absurd, while Duff is probably not. So this is a hybrid piece of shit. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

58 minutes ago, Budd Dwyer said:

Yeah, that's why he is making millions of millions of millions of dollars in the past 35 years lol

 

Imagine that being on  this shit bands forum and you actually come up with this revisionist NUGNR bullshit even after the fatunion

We all can criticise the top hatted asshole for what he is now, but you cannot take away his legacy (which NUGNR nutswingers tend to do all t the time...)

How the fuck you and your ilk became GNR fans in the first place lol

 

 

I haven’t taken away his legacy, the guy has done great things, his accomplishments are undeniable, I said so in my previous post (the one you’re quoting). So I’m not sure what you’re aiming at.

 

Making money is not an indication of much. Based on numbers we could say Justin Bieber or Taylor Swift are way better musicians than Slash, GNR, Led Zep… pretty dumb way to assess skill, right?

 

I think you’re too emotionally tied to what this band once was and/or to Slash, and your posts are a sort of knee jerk reaction without much substance other than the retarded “nugnr nutswinger” idiocy.

 

Slash is good, relax.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, creed said:

Brain is on Absurd, while Duff is probably not. So this is a hybrid piece of shit. 

 

Duff is def on absurd.  Those bass lines in the new version were not on the BBF version.   Also we should hope Brain is on all of the next album tracks since Frank sucks.  Some people think its Bucket doing the tapping at the start of the song.  It could be Fortus but you are right they could also have Bucket, Finck, and Brain on the tracks with Slash and Duff

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Budd Dwyer said:

that's true though but what can you do with a bunch of pro tools licks?

That has nothing to do with their skills.

 

Axl had a fucked up way of working, and they had to adapt to that. The lack of material in any form (even full fleshed demos, the most basic version of any song) is on Axl. The guys did their part. And came up with good songs. Whether or not you consider that gnr is irrelevant.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, dave-gnfnr2k said:

 

Duff is def on absurd.  Those bass lines in the new version were not on the BBF version.   Also we should hope Brain is on all of the next album tracks since Frank sucks.  Some people think its Bucket doing the tapping at the start of the song.  It could be Fortus but you are right they could also have Bucket, Finck, and Brain on the tracks with Slash and Duff

 

 

sometimes I think frank is only the tour drummer and brain is the studio one

cause they never made an official announcement of brain quiting the band and there's also that time on the chat that axl said that brain was still a part of the band

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, suiccidematt said:

sometimes I think frank is only the tour drummer and brain is the studio one

cause they never made an official announcement of brain quiting the band and there's also that time on the chat that axl said that brain was still a part of the band

 

 

 

yeah exactly. I remember after Frank joined they said that Brain is still in the band like you said.  Hopefully Brain is on most of the songs because he is way better.  Maybe they will just do what they did on CD and give Frank one full song and keep brain on the rest.  All frank really did on the other CD songs was add some fills here and there that were not even needed 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, dave-gnfnr2k said:

 

yeah exactly. I remember after Frank joined they said that Brain is still in the band like you said.  Hopefully Brain is on most of the songs because he is way better.  Maybe they will just do what they did on CD and give Frank one full song and keep brain on the rest.  All frank really did on the other CD songs was add some fills here and there that were not even needed 

hopefully is gonna be this!

honestly, although I like frank it would be better if they just bring brain back. his style of playing fits the band better

frank has a too soft hand

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Budd Dwyer said:

How so?

Bach (the real one, not the glam metal poseur) will always be better than any guitarist lol. That's why they rip him off all the time

 

Btw those are just instrumentals which went nowhere, not even used on the big comeback album, gee i wonder why...

Curly Shuffle would have been an argument, but you actually forgot that to mention lol

it's a matter of taste, but you need actual "feel" to the guitars,  it's music 1*1, even a 12 year old can shred lol

TWAT is the closest to Anastasia when it comes to good playing though

Bach the "the glam metal poseur". Christ you are some fucking twat. Bach is a man possessing one of the best voices in the history of rock and sang on one of the greatest rock albums of the 90s - Slave to the Grind. What the fuck have you done with your life? You absolute cretin. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

26 minutes ago, suiccidematt said:

sometimes I think frank is only the tour drummer and brain is the studio one

cause they never made an official announcement of brain quiting the band and there's also that time on the chat that axl said that brain was still a part of the band

 

 

I think this too. He also works with Melissa. 
 

frank rerecorded a couple CD tracks though 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Norespect said:

Bach the "the glam metal poseur". Christ you are some fucking twat. Bach is a man possessing one of the best voices in the history of rock and sang on one of the greatest rock albums of the 90s - Slave to the Grind. What the fuck have you done with your life? You absolute cretin. 

so you're trolling i see

Bach is a shadow of his former self (like most of his contemporaries) and i don't particularly like Skid Row either

 

 

Greatest rock albums of the 90's, gimme a break lol

 

which alt are you?

 

Quote

What the fuck have you done with your life? Y

Developing a better musical taste than yours lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, dave-gnfnr2k said:

 

Duff is def on absurd.  Those bass lines in the new version were not on the BBF version.   Also we should hope Brain is on all of the next album tracks since Frank sucks.  Some people think its Bucket doing the tapping at the start of the song.  It could be Fortus but you are right they could also have Bucket, Finck, and Brain on the tracks with Slash and Duff

 

 

Duff also does some background vocals that replace synth in the earlier versions. I was wondering why the fuck he was at the mic during the live performances, but if you have decent headphones you can hear him doing a vocal take on what was a mid range synth previously.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is that video on Youtube the one Axl said back in 2008 would be out in a week or so, "soon is the word"?  It's not like it was needed for any of those songs.

 

I have to admit, it would be entirely listenable if they threw out all that noise and just had Slash and Duff lead the other employees in a jam to recreate the same thing the way they do on stage.  As it is, what are they getting out of this?  I have no idea if either of them are even on the new release and Axl owns 100% of every single thing G'n'R has done since 1996 (all sixteen songs) so it's not like he'll share any credit with them.  It's not like it'll get played on radio or MTV anyway.

 

The point of a two-guitar rock band is one guy on lead, the other on rhythm.  Why the hell does Axl have any interest whatsoever on several guitarists all playing lead at once?  The whole thing is like he put in the maximum amount of effort all these years to create as little as possible and this song/video are what he has to show for it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Dr. Thunder said:

Duff also does some background vocals that replace synth in the earlier versions. I was wondering why the fuck he was at the mic during the live performances, but if you have decent headphones you can hear him doing a vocal take on what was a mid range synth previously.

Johnnny!!!!

AXXEEELL!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...